Not Everyone Can Be a Designer

Monday, April 10th, 2023

Not Everyone Can Be a Designer

The field of graphic design is often misconstrued as an effortless profession, but this couldn’t be further from the truth. It is an intricate craft that demands a mix of technical expertise, creative innovation, and critical thinking. When only viewing the final product, it’s easy to miss the hard work that goes into the creation process.

There’s a widespread, erroneous misconception that design software can do all the work for you. However, in reality, graphic design is an art form that requires more than technical proficiency. A skilled designer understands the principles of design, including typography, color theory, and composition. They also need to convey complex information in a visually appealing and comprehensible manner.

Ultimately, graphic design is not solely about making something aesthetically pleasing; it is a complex and challenging field that necessitates both artistic flair and proficiency. So, while it may be tempting to underestimate the profession, it requires a unique combination of skills and knowledge.

Creativity is Key

Creativity is an essential skill for success in the world of graphic design. It is the foundation of producing designs that communicate messages with visual impact and effectively achieve the requirements of clients. However, creativity in graphic design is more than just about aesthetics.

To be a great graphic designer, one must create designs that are both visually appealing and satisfy the client’s specific objectives. But, as with any creative endeavor, it’s difficult to produce unique ideas. Nevertheless, with dedication and hard work, it’s possible to develop the skill of creativity. Evenso, if it is not for everyone.

If generating innovative ideas and thinking beyond the norm is challenging, then a career in graphic design may not be the right fit. Ultimately, creativity is the cornerstone of graphic design, and those who can master it can become truly outstanding designers.

Case study: The Tropicana redesign in 2009

Tropicana, to appeal to a younger market, employed the renowned advertising agency, Arnell, to overhaul its packaging in 2008. The new design was intended to be modern, minimalist, and stylish. But throughout the process, it lost the imaginative touch that had made the original packaging so iconic and memorable.

The new design featured a glass of orange juice instead of the brand’s traditional orange. It also used a more generic font, resulting in a less recognizable look. The public swiftly reacted negatively to the redesign, and sales declined by 20% (about $20M).

Tropicana took prompt action and reinstated the original packaging, resulting in a remarkable increase in sales. The Tropicana redesign serves as a compelling example of how a graphic designer’s lack of creativity can harm brand recognition and a company’s financial performance. It serves as a reminder that design trends may come and go, but creativity and originality are fundamental components of effective design.

Technical Skills

Graphic design goes beyond creativity; it requires technical skills to transform ideas into tangible designs. Designers must be proficient in software tools such as Adobe Illustrator, Photoshop, and InDesign to produce top-notch designs.

However, mastering these software tools requires time, dedication, and practice. It’s not solely about comprehending the fundamentals but also staying up to date with the most recent industry trends and developments. For those who struggle with technology or are reluctant to learn new software, graphic design may not be the optimal career path.

Case study: The website in 2013

The website was intended to provide access to health insurance for millions of Americans through the Affordable Care Act. However, when it was released in October 2013, the website was riddled with technical problems that made it impossible for users to sign up.

The Obama administration was embarrassed by the website’s rocky launch. Subsequent investigation revealed that many of the issues were due to substandard design and coding practices. A team of contractors created the website, many of whom were not up to the task of building a website of such size and complexity.

The issues delayed the website’s rollout by several months. Even after it went live, users encountered long wait times, incorrect information, and error messages. People criticized the design of the site, disappointed that it was so it was convoluted and difficult to navigate.

The technical problems with had a significant impact on the success of the Affordable Care Act. The negative publicity surrounding the site’s launch eroded public confidence in the program, and it took months for the website to become fully functional.

The fiasco serves as a stark reminder of the importance of technical skills in design. Creating a functional, efficient website requires technical ability. A graphic designer who lacks technical proficiency may produce an aesthetically pleasing design. But if the design is not supported by a solid and well-constructed website, it can jeopardize the success of a project.

Attention to Detail

When it comes to graphic design, every little detail matters. Designers must be meticulous, taking into consideration every element of the design. Every detail, from the size of the font to the colors used, ensures that the final product aligns with the client’s goals.

Errors, no matter how small, can have a major impact on the final design. For instance, a typo or an incorrect color can drastically alter the intended message of a design. Attention to detail is a skill that not everyone possesses naturally. It requires practice, dedication, and a great deal of focus. This can be tedious and frustrating for some. Nonetheless, it is a crucial component of effective design, one that can make all the difference in creating successful and impactful designs.

Case study: The London 2012 Olympic Games logo

The 2007 unveiling of the London Games Olympic logo was met with immediate and harsh criticism. Critics believed that the logo was too abstract and failed to embody the spirit of the Olympic Games. Unfortunately, the controversy did not end there.

Shortly after the logo’s unveiling, the public also uncovered an unintended hidden message in the design. When the logo was rotated counterclockwise by 90 degrees, it spelled out the word “ZION.” This discovery raised concerns among some that the logo had a hidden political or religious agenda.

The logo’s designer, Wolff Olins, denied including any intentionally hidden messages in the design. They explained that the logo was meant to be a modern representation of the Olympic Games and to appeal to a younger generation. Despite the explanation, the controversy had a significant impact on the public’s perception of the Olympic Games and the logo’s design.

The lack of attention to detail in the Olympic logo’s design had far-reaching consequences, affecting not only the designers but also the Olympic Committee. It damaged the public’s perception of the Games. It serves as a cautionary tale of how even the smallest oversight in a design can have significant consequences, further highlighting why attention to detail is an essential skill for graphic designers.

Communication Skills

Communication skills are paramount for graphic designers. They must be adept at comprehending the client’s goals and transforming them into a visual representation. Moreover, they must be able to articulate their design concepts skillfully to clients, coworkers, and other relevant parties.

Effective communication skills are crucial to guarantee that the end product meets the client’s standards. Those who struggle with communication or have trouble expressing their ideas, may not find graphic design to be the most suitable profession.

Case study: The Gap logo redesign in 2010

The Gap clothing retailer’s 201o rebranding initiative, which included a redesign of the company’s logo, was met with an unexpected backlash. The new design featured a simple Helvetica font with a small blue gradient box, which many found to be generic and lacking the brand’s iconic identity. Additionally, the company was criticized for not effectively communicating the reasons for the logo redesign and rebranding initiative to its customers.

The negative response to the logo redesign had a significant impact on the company’s reputation and market performance. The company’s executives were forced to respond to the criticism and ultimately decided to revert to the old logo.

This case serves as a reminder of the importance of effective communication skills in graphic design. A designer must effectively convey design decisions, strategies, and rationale to clients and audiences to ensure that designs align with the brand’s vision and identity. Without effective communication, misunderstandings and negative responses are more likely. In the end, this leads to reputational damage and poor market performance.

The Ability to Work Under Pressure

The ability to work efficiently under tight deadlines is a crucial skill for graphic designers. The design process often involves multiple stages, and delays can impact the project’s timeline and budget. Successful graphic designers manage their time effectively, prioritize their tasks, and deliver high-quality designs on time.

However, working under pressure is not for everyone. The fast-paced and high-stress environment of graphic design can be overwhelming for some individuals. Those who struggle with managing their stress levels or have difficulty working under tight deadlines may find the demands of graphic design to be too challenging. Aspiring graphic designers need to understand the demands of the profession and determine if it aligns with their work style and personality.

Case study: The Facebook IPO prospectus

The story of Facebook’s IPO prospectus design is a cautionary tale of the consequences of failing to work under pressure. The graphic designer hired to create the legal document was faced with a tight deadline and high expectations from the company’s executives and investors. Under such pressure, the designer made a crucial mistake in the prospectus that had serious repercussions for the IPO.

The error in the prospectus statement suggested that Facebook’s revenue growth was declining, causing panic among investors and leading to a drop in the company’s stock price. The mistake was later traced back to the designer’s failure to properly check the data before including it in the prospectus.

The design mistake had a major impact, with Facebook’s stock price plummeting by over 50% in the months following the IPO. The incident raised concerns about the company’s financial performance and long-term viability.

The Facebook IPO prospectus design error is a stark reminder that even under tight deadlines and high-pressure situations, graphic designers must maintain their attention to detail. Failure to do so results in significant consequences for the designer, the company, and its investors.

Continuous Learning

To remain relevant in an ever-changing industry, graphic designers must stay up-to-date with the latest trends and technology. Designers must invest time and effort in continuous learning to enhance their skills and knowledge.

However, staying on top of the latest trends and updates can be a daunting task for some designers. It requires a strong commitment to lifelong learning, and a willingness to adapt to changes in the industry. For those who struggle with keeping up with the latest updates and trends, a career in graphic design may not be the ideal choice.

Case study: The rebranding of Weight Watchers in 2019

In 2019, Weight Watchers – the go-to weight-loss program – decided to rebrand. Amidst the process, they opted for a new name, WW, and expanded their focus to encompass overall wellness and healthy living. To accompany the shift in its brand identity, the company introduced a fresh visual style, including a revamped logo and color palette.

Sadly, the new branding was quickly met with criticism from designers who found it lacked the contemporary and modern style that the health and wellness industry was exuding. Critics deemed it outdated and unable to keep up with the latest design trends. Several critics also noted that the rebranding failed to effectively communicate the company’s new emphasis on overall wellness, saying the logo and branding appeared disconnected from their new messaging.

This negative feedback had a massive impact on the company’s reputation and market performance. Weight Watchers’ executives had to address the issue and ended up making some tweaks to the branding to address the criticisms.

This incident emphasizes the importance of staying up-to-date with the latest design trends and developments in the industry. Graphic designers must continuously remain informed and aware of the latest trends, technologies, and industry advancements to create visually compelling identities that resonate with audiences. If designers fail to keep up, they risk developing outdated branding that fails to connect with audiences and achieve the desired outcomes.

Ability to Take Feedback

As a graphic designer, you need to be receptive to feedback from your clients, colleagues, and other stakeholders. Constructive criticism is a powerful tool that can help you elevate your design game. To be successful in this field, it’s crucial to communicate your design choices and rationale effectively.

Accepting feedback is easier said than done. Criticism can be tough to take. It can shake your confidence and affect your creative abilities. If you’re someone who struggles with taking feedback or explaining your design choices, graphic design may not be the right fit for you.

Case study: Snapchat’s user interface redesign in 2018

Snapchat’s redesign aimed to make the app more user-friendly and appealing to a broader audience. However, upon its release, the new design was met with swift criticism from users who found the interface confusing and difficult to navigate.

Despite the negative feedback, the design team initially refused to make changes, believing that the redesign was a necessary and positive change. Nevertheless, the backlash grew, with users demanding a return to the old interface. Dome celebrities, including Kylie Jenner, publicly expressed their disapproval of the new design.

The result was a significant loss of users from the app, who flocked to other social media platforms that offered a more user-friendly interface.

This case demonstrates the importance of listening to and acting on feedback when designing a product. Graphic designers must be willing to receive and act on feedback, even if it runs counter to their original vision. In this instance, the design team’s refusal to acknowledge and address user feedback resulted in a decrease in the app’s popularity and user base.

Passion for Design

Passion is a key ingredient for success in the field of graphic design. It’s more than just a job; it’s a way of life. Designers need to have an unquenchable thirst for the design process and constantly search for inspiration to create new and original design concepts.

This passion cannot be taught or learned; it’s an inherent quality that drives designers to produce their best work. Those who lack a genuine passion for design may find it difficult to thrive in the fast-paced and dynamic world of graphic design.

Case study: The Premier League rebranding in 2019

The Premier League, one of the world’s most famous and profitable sports leagues, embarked on a rebranding campaign in 2019 to update its visual identity. The league enlisted a design agency to create a new logo, color scheme, and overall visual identity for the league.

The unveiling of the new brand was met with immediate criticism from fans. They found the new logo unexciting and uninspiring. Many of the league’s followers and critics also believed that the new branding lacked the energy and excitement of the league’s fast-paced and thrilling games.

The design agency responsible for the rebranding was accused of lacking a profound understanding and passion for soccer and the Premier League. Many supporters felt that the new branding failed to capture the essence and excitement of the league, presenting a cold and unoriginal visual identity.

The negative reaction to the rebranding significantly impacted the league’s reputation and fan engagement. The executives of the Premier League were obliged to address the adverse feedback and ultimately decided to revert to the previous branding. They conceded that the rebranding campaign did not accomplish its intended objectives.

This case demonstrates the importance of having passion and comprehension in graphic design. Designers must connect with and understand the essence and energy of the product or service they are designing for. They also need a passion for the craft of design to create compelling visual identities.

To be a successful graphic designer, you must have a passion for design that goes beyond just a job; it’s a way of life. Designers need to immerse themselves in the design process and continuously seek inspiration to come up with fresh and innovative design ideas.

In graphic design, it takes a unique combination of skills to create compelling visuals that capture the essence of a brand. Attention to detail, technical know-how, creativity, the ability to handle feedback, and a passion for design are just some of the abilities that a designer needs.

While many of the necessary skills are unlearnable, not everyone is cut out to be a graphic designer. It takes a certain type of person with a particular set of skills to excel in this field. Evaluate your strengths and limitations to determine if graphic design is the right path for you.

If you have a passion for design and creativity, graphic design can be a truly fulfilling and rewarding career choice. But, if you lack some of the necessary skills, it may be wise to consider other paths that align better with your strengths and interests.

The bottom line is that graphic design is a challenging and rewarding field that demands the best from those who choose to pursue it. If you have what it takes, step up to the challenge and become the best graphic designer you can be. If not, don’t worry – there are many other paths out there waiting for you to explore.

About Matcha Design

Matcha Design is a full-service creative B2B agency with decades of experience executing its client’s visions. The award-winning company specializes in web design, logo design, branding, marketing campaign, print, UX/UI, video production, commercial photography, advertising, and more. Matcha Design upholds the highest personal standards for excellence and can see things from a unique perspective due to its multicultural background.  The company consistently delivers custom, high-quality, innovative solutions to its clients using technical savvy and endless creativity. For more information, visit

Related Tags

You Might Also Like